Licensed NYC Secondhand Dealer • 30+ Years Experience • Immediate Payment • Private Appointments • Trusted by Hundreds of NYC Clients
Sell Gold Coins & Bullion in New York City
American Eagles, Buffalos, Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, bars and silver coins — weighed and verified in front of you, with immediate payment.
- Licensed NYC Secondhand Dealer
- 30+ Years of Experience
- Immediate Payment
- Free Professional Evaluation
- Private & Secure Manhattan Office
Receive a Professional Coin & Bullion Evaluation
Whether you're selling a single American Gold Eagle, an inherited coin collection, or an investment position in bullion, Gold Buyers Club offers a transparent, confidential buying experience with immediate payment.
For over 30 years, investors, collectors and families throughout New York City have trusted us to purchase gold and silver coins at competitive, market-based prices.
Every coin is verified and weighed by experienced buyers in a private office on Manhattan's Upper East Side.
The Standard of Excellence
Why Sell Your Coins to Gold Buyers Club?
Licensed NYC Secondhand Dealer
We are a licensed New York City Secondhand Dealer with decades of experience purchasing coins and bullion.
Market-Based Offers
Bullion coins are priced against the live spot market, so you can see how your offer was reached.
Immediate Payment
Accept our offer and receive payment immediately. No consignments, no auction waits, no seller's commission.
Private & Secure
High-value bullion transactions are handled discreetly in our secure Manhattan office.
Inventory & Acquisition
The Coins & Bullion We Buy
American Gold Coins
- American Gold Eagles
- American Gold Buffalos
- Pre-1933 US gold coins
- Gold Double Eagles
- American Gold Eagle fractionals
International Gold Coins
- Canadian Maple Leafs
- South African Krugerrands
- Chinese Pandas
- Austrian Philharmonics
- British Sovereigns and Britannias
- Mexican Pesos
Gold Bullion
- Gold bars in all sizes
- Gold ingots
- Gold rounds
- Assay-carded bullion
- Investment-grade bullion lots
Silver Coins
- American Silver Eagles
- Morgan Silver Dollars
- Peace Dollars
- Junk silver coins
- Silver bullion and bars
We buy silver coins, but we do not purchase silver jewelry.
Collections We Purchase
- Inherited coin collections
- Estate bullion holdings
- Safe deposit box contents
- Investment positions
- Accumulated bullion lots
Also Accepted
- Graded and slabbed coins
- Original mint packaging and certificates
- Platinum bullion
Bring certificates and original packaging where you still have them — they can help.
Appointments are recommended for larger collections and high-value bullion so we can allocate the time and privacy the transaction deserves.
Transparent Valuation
What Determines Your Coins' Value?
Bullion and collectible coins are valued differently, and we tell you which basis we're using for each item.
Metal Content
Gold or silver weight and purity set the floor value for any bullion coin.
Current Spot Price
Precious metals trade continuously. Offers reflect the market at the time of your visit.
Coin Type & Mintage
Scarcer issues and low-mintage years can carry a premium above metal value.
Condition & Grade
Wear, cleaning and handling affect collectible value more than bullion value.
Certification
Coins graded by services such as PCGS or NGC are faster to evaluate, though certification is never required.
Collector Demand
Numismatic premiums move with collector interest, independently of the metal market.
How It Works
Selling Your Coins Is Easy
Schedule or Visit
Schedule an appointment or bring your coins to our Manhattan office.
Verified & Weighed
Each coin is verified and weighed in front of you.
Review Our Offer
See the basis for every item, with no obligation to sell.
Immediate Payment
Accept the offer and receive immediate payment.
What Our Clients Say
Read our reviews on Google★★★★★
“The evaluation was thorough and completely transparent. Everything was weighed and tested in front of me, and the offer was explained piece by piece.”
★★★★★
“I had no paperwork for the diamond and expected that to be a problem. It wasn't. Professional, private, and payment was immediate.”
★★★★★
“Discreet office, no pressure, and a far better offer than the two other buyers I visited that week.”
Placeholder testimonials — pending client-supplied Google review quotes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you buy a single coin?
Yes. Whether it's one American Gold Eagle or an entire collection, we're happy to help.
Do coins need to be graded or certified?
No. Certification can speed up an evaluation, but we regularly purchase raw, uncertified coins.
Should I clean my coins before bringing them in?
Please don't. Cleaning can reduce a collectible coin's value. Bring them exactly as they are.
Do you buy silver as well as gold?
Yes, we purchase silver coins and silver bullion. We do not purchase silver jewelry.
Is the evaluation free?
Yes. Every evaluation is complimentary with no obligation to sell.
Why Investors Trust Gold Buyers Club
- Licensed NYC Secondhand Dealer
- Over 30 Years Experience
- Market-Based Pricing
- Immediate Payment
- No Seller's Commission
- Complimentary Evaluations
- Private & Secure Office
- Convenient Upper East Side Location
Ready to Sell Your Coins or Bullion?
Schedule a private appointment with one of our experienced buyers, or call today to discuss your holdings.
14 East 60th Street, Suite 802
New York, NY 10022
- Monday – Friday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday: By Appointment Only
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 4:00 PM